A while back, I posted about how critiquing can be valuable for writers - not just the process of getting outside eyes on your work, but the act of reading critically, bringing your reactions together, and phrasing them in an effective manner. Today, I wanted to talk about how I approach the critiques I receive: how I filter them, decide how to proceed, what advice to use and what to ignore.
Important to everything that follows is this: take critique with a grain of salt. Not every reader is bothered by the same issues. It may only be an "issue" for a particular individual. I've received rejections-with-comments from editors that offer contradictory reasons and comments. Once, I got a rejection on a story criticizing its florid prose. The same story got praise for the lyrical descriptions ... from the very next place I submitted it.
(Some of you may be thinking: what about the writers who are so arrogant they brush off anything that isn't praise? I'm sure they're out there, but in my experience, they're the minority. Most of us hate everything we've written and are prone to believe every negative word.)
In most critique situations, you have more than one reader. Now, I know perfectly well that the best way to deal with this is to wait until all (or at least some) of the responses have come in before changing anything ... but I have a compulsion to apply and "resolve" the critique as soon as possible, so I'd be a hypocrite to advise others to wait.
I analyze each comment in a critique and decide how I feel about it: whether I agree, disagree or am on the fence. This involves knowing myself as a writer, what I want out of the story, and of course the content of the story. (Readers are human, and I have gotten comments / confusion about a fact that is directly stated - but I've also been sure I said X, and gone back to find that wasn't the case ...)
If I agree with the comment, I will make the change right away. Easy enough.
If I'm not sure whether the point is valid or not, I will put it on hold until I hear if others agree with it.
If I disagree with a point ... yeah, I tend to discard it, though not always. If others echo the same concern, I will go back and take another look. I also look at the objection and the reasoning behind it. Sometimes, there's a way to address it in another fashion. Let's say a critique says (this is awful blunt, but let's go with it): "This character is boring. Cut them." I could remove the character entirely ... or I could amp her up and justify her place in the story. Not every reader will explain or even know the reason behind their comments, so it's up to the writer to do a bit of detective work ... even go to the reader directly, if you can do it without being confrontational.
Also, sometimes it's just about what I want the story to be. For instance, I wrote a short story once with a supporting character who betrayed the main character. The ending affirmed his decision and his true colors ... and people hated it. They wanted him to be redeemed, but that was never my intention. In a way, maybe it was a backhanded compliment: they liked him enough to want him to be a good guy.
Finally, sometimes it's about knowing your audience and their tastes. Sometimes, they'll tell you ("I hate happy endings") and sometimes, if you've dealt with the same people for a while, you'll already know. Personally, I hate first person present tense with a passion unless there's some pressing reason for it. It doesn't convey any more immediacy, to me; I just find it distracting and unbookish. (That is not a word. I know.) As a critique partner, I will note this directly - "I hate first person present tense and I didn't mind it at all here" or "I should preface this with the fact that I hate first person present tense, but I don't think it worked here ..." - but not everyone does. But your reader's tastes may add a few extra pinches of salt to a comment.
It's all a delicate balance between believing in your story and trusting that outside eyes will make it stronger. Go too far in either direction, and the story suffers. Even if you change an oddball story to appeal to a wider audience, it may no longer be the story you want to tell ... and to me, that is the more important part.
Quotes, musings, tidbits and news from speculative fiction author Lindsey Duncan - click over to This Site for her website.
About Me
- Lindsey Duncan
- I'm a professional harp performer, chef / pastry chef, and speculative fiction writer from Cincinnati, Ohio. My contemporary fantasy novel Flow is available from Double Dragon Publishing, and my science fiction novel Scylla and Charybdis is now out from Grimbold Books. I've also sold a number of short stories and a few pieces of speculative poetry. I write predominantly fantasy, usually epic and/or humorous, with some soft science fiction. I play the traditional lever harp with a specialty in Celtic music - but I also perform modern and Renaissance tunes. And yes, you read that right - I have a diploma in Baking and Pastry and an Associates in Culinary Arts and am currently working in the catering field at Kate's Catering and Personal Chef Services (Dayton, KY). I am a CPC (Certified Pastry Culinarian) and CSW (Certified Specialist of Wine).
Wednesday, January 17, 2018
Sunday, January 14, 2018
Song Styles
I've always thought that song lyrics, out of context, can make excellent story prompts for writers. For my flash / poetry boot camp, I took a line from a Rihanna song - "I'm lost, you've got me looking for the rest of me" - though I didn't end up using that particular prompt. I also once challenged a group of writers with this gem from the Sondheim musical Into The Woods:
I'll see you soon again; I hope that when I do, it won't be on a plate.
The results were well worth the irritable reactions.
But one of my favorite from-lyrics prompts has to come out of Heather Nova's Maybe An Angel:
And when you said that you were dead, I hung on.
It's a line that doesn't make sense even in context, granted, but it suggests so many things, particularly for a writer like me who is fascinated with afterlives.
I'll see you soon again; I hope that when I do, it won't be on a plate.
The results were well worth the irritable reactions.
But one of my favorite from-lyrics prompts has to come out of Heather Nova's Maybe An Angel:
And when you said that you were dead, I hung on.
It's a line that doesn't make sense even in context, granted, but it suggests so many things, particularly for a writer like me who is fascinated with afterlives.
Sunday, January 07, 2018
Song Styles
New year, new car CDs? Not really, actually: I swapped them out mid-December. I've stopped sharing my other themes, seeing as my music choices wander between the obscure and the obvious, but I do like sharing my odd thought process for my word association CD: where the songs link by title and occasionally topic through stream of consciousness connection.
So here's my most recent collection, including some brand-new acquisitions:
Spin - Rachel Fuller
Dancin' in Circles - Lady Gaga
Circle of Stone - Laura Powers (song treats the stone circle as an otherworld gateway, so ...)
Underworld - Joss Stone
Afterlife - Ingrid Michaelson
Death of Love - Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Would You Call That Love - Kelly Clarkson
He Never Mentioned Love - Kirsty MacColl
Never Said - Liz Phair
The Last Words You Said - Sarah Brightman
Last Letter - Katharine McPhee
Writing On The Wall - Blackmore's Night
The Walls Keep Saying Your Name - Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Four Pink Walls - Alessia Cara (I consider this a metaphor for heart walls, so ...)
Into My Heart - Rachel Fuller
Bringin' On The Heartbreak - Mariah Carey
How To Be A Heartbreaker - Marina and the Diamonds
How To Touch A Girl - JoJo
Touch Me - Kirsty MacColl
Don't Touch Me There - Dian Diaz
Don't - Jewel
I Didn't - Kristin Chenoweth
Didn't I - Kelly Clarkson
I Didn't Plan It - Sara Bareilles
Wild Child - Enya
Children Of The World - Amy Grant
Small World - Idina Menzel
Our Little World - Into The Woods soundtrack
Too Little, Too Late - JoJo
It's Too Late - Gloria Estefan
Midnight Heartache - September
Midnight Bottle - Colbie Caillat
Bottle It Up - Sara Bareilles
Hold Me Down - Halsey
Bow Down - Chvrches
I Bow Out - Whitney Houston
Take a Bow - Leona Lewis
Applause - Lady Gaga
Private Show - P!nk
Show Me - Idina Menzel
Reveal - Celine Dion
So here's my most recent collection, including some brand-new acquisitions:
Spin - Rachel Fuller
Dancin' in Circles - Lady Gaga
Circle of Stone - Laura Powers (song treats the stone circle as an otherworld gateway, so ...)
Underworld - Joss Stone
Afterlife - Ingrid Michaelson
Death of Love - Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Would You Call That Love - Kelly Clarkson
He Never Mentioned Love - Kirsty MacColl
Never Said - Liz Phair
The Last Words You Said - Sarah Brightman
Last Letter - Katharine McPhee
Writing On The Wall - Blackmore's Night
The Walls Keep Saying Your Name - Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Four Pink Walls - Alessia Cara (I consider this a metaphor for heart walls, so ...)
Into My Heart - Rachel Fuller
Bringin' On The Heartbreak - Mariah Carey
How To Be A Heartbreaker - Marina and the Diamonds
How To Touch A Girl - JoJo
Touch Me - Kirsty MacColl
Don't Touch Me There - Dian Diaz
Don't - Jewel
I Didn't - Kristin Chenoweth
Didn't I - Kelly Clarkson
I Didn't Plan It - Sara Bareilles
Wild Child - Enya
Children Of The World - Amy Grant
Small World - Idina Menzel
Our Little World - Into The Woods soundtrack
Too Little, Too Late - JoJo
It's Too Late - Gloria Estefan
Midnight Heartache - September
Midnight Bottle - Colbie Caillat
Bottle It Up - Sara Bareilles
Hold Me Down - Halsey
Bow Down - Chvrches
I Bow Out - Whitney Houston
Take a Bow - Leona Lewis
Applause - Lady Gaga
Private Show - P!nk
Show Me - Idina Menzel
Reveal - Celine Dion
Wednesday, January 03, 2018
Wednesday Wanderings
The end of the year was tumultuous, hence my radio silence over the past few weeks. I've never been much for New Year's resolutions, though I do swear by setting goals; I simply don't hold much stock in waiting until or focusing on the first of the year. The calendar is arbitrary, after all.
On the culinary front, I have some solid goals, though they're mainly coming about now because I've settled into my new job and have time to breathe after the holiday madness. There are some professional certifications I intend to obtain over the next year; two of them are fairly pro forma (just taking a test to put a rubber stamp on what I already know, maybe with a little brush-up), and one of them is long-term, which I won't qualify for until August - one of the requirements is a certain length of work experience.
On the harp front, I don't have any specific goals, but I have a potential new student and a number of gigs through the first few months of the year. That should keep me busy for a while.
On the writing front, I must admit I'm at a bit of a loss. The only goals I can think of either involve external gatekeeping (sell short stories to professional markets; acquire an agent; sell a novel to a major publisher) or more of the same old (finish writing / editing a novel, write a certain number of short stories / poems / flash). I know I want to get more involved with beta readers and maybe a small critique group, but I'm not sure of the logistics or the details I want.
Thoughts welcome, but for now ... onwards. That's the important thing.
On the culinary front, I have some solid goals, though they're mainly coming about now because I've settled into my new job and have time to breathe after the holiday madness. There are some professional certifications I intend to obtain over the next year; two of them are fairly pro forma (just taking a test to put a rubber stamp on what I already know, maybe with a little brush-up), and one of them is long-term, which I won't qualify for until August - one of the requirements is a certain length of work experience.
On the harp front, I don't have any specific goals, but I have a potential new student and a number of gigs through the first few months of the year. That should keep me busy for a while.
On the writing front, I must admit I'm at a bit of a loss. The only goals I can think of either involve external gatekeeping (sell short stories to professional markets; acquire an agent; sell a novel to a major publisher) or more of the same old (finish writing / editing a novel, write a certain number of short stories / poems / flash). I know I want to get more involved with beta readers and maybe a small critique group, but I'm not sure of the logistics or the details I want.
Thoughts welcome, but for now ... onwards. That's the important thing.
Wednesday, December 20, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
This is why we can't have nice things, Christmas edition.
So one of my mother's favorite Christmas desserts, and a holiday tradition in our house for many years, is red velvet cake with boiled buttercream. I've never been a big fan; the frosting is too sweet, and as far as I could see, the only difference between red velvet cake and any other cake was food coloring. (I've since learned a bit more about it, and there really isn't that much more difference: red velvet cake uses a bit of vinegar and a small amount of cocoa powder, not enough to qualify it as a chocolate cake and - more importantly - not enough to inhibit the color. Suffice to say, I'm still not impressed.)
But every year, red velvet cake, and I'll have a piece, but I can take it or leave it.
Another convention, this one born from necessity: we kept desserts that needed to be chilled outside in the garage, sealed, on top of the cars. In the case of the red velvet cake, we had a cake cover.
So one day I get into my car to drive to an appointment. I turn onto a road that is an overpass over the highway ... and all of a sudden, I see something white fly past in my rear view mirror, followed by ...
Yep, that's the cake. Cover, cake, plate and all whooshed off the top of my car and landed on the bridge over the highway.
I swear there was no subliminal malevolence about it, but I don't think I ever even retrieved the cover, because it was *over the highway.*
So one of my mother's favorite Christmas desserts, and a holiday tradition in our house for many years, is red velvet cake with boiled buttercream. I've never been a big fan; the frosting is too sweet, and as far as I could see, the only difference between red velvet cake and any other cake was food coloring. (I've since learned a bit more about it, and there really isn't that much more difference: red velvet cake uses a bit of vinegar and a small amount of cocoa powder, not enough to qualify it as a chocolate cake and - more importantly - not enough to inhibit the color. Suffice to say, I'm still not impressed.)
But every year, red velvet cake, and I'll have a piece, but I can take it or leave it.
Another convention, this one born from necessity: we kept desserts that needed to be chilled outside in the garage, sealed, on top of the cars. In the case of the red velvet cake, we had a cake cover.
So one day I get into my car to drive to an appointment. I turn onto a road that is an overpass over the highway ... and all of a sudden, I see something white fly past in my rear view mirror, followed by ...
Yep, that's the cake. Cover, cake, plate and all whooshed off the top of my car and landed on the bridge over the highway.
I swear there was no subliminal malevolence about it, but I don't think I ever even retrieved the cover, because it was *over the highway.*
Sunday, December 17, 2017
Sunday ... Shopping?
Tis the season for ... frantic commercialism? Perhaps not, but if you're looking for a gift to give to support a starving artist, perhaps consider:
My contemporary fantasy novel Flow
OR
The traditional music of Rolling Of The Stone, from Scottish to Renaissance to Medieval and other Celtic lands
For a seasonal taste of what I write, my story Xmas Wishes is available from Gypsy Shadow Publishing, as is Taming The Weald.
Want to give a taste of several authors? (Or just keep it for yourself!) Some anthologies I recommend, from complete and total bias:
Unburied Treasure (with fantastic illustrations!)
Trespass
Light of the Last Day
The Best of Abyss and Apex Vol 1
In conclusion, support a small press artist this season. Even if it's not me. ;-)
My contemporary fantasy novel Flow
OR
The traditional music of Rolling Of The Stone, from Scottish to Renaissance to Medieval and other Celtic lands
For a seasonal taste of what I write, my story Xmas Wishes is available from Gypsy Shadow Publishing, as is Taming The Weald.
Want to give a taste of several authors? (Or just keep it for yourself!) Some anthologies I recommend, from complete and total bias:
Unburied Treasure (with fantastic illustrations!)
Trespass
Light of the Last Day
The Best of Abyss and Apex Vol 1
In conclusion, support a small press artist this season. Even if it's not me. ;-)
Thursday, December 14, 2017
Thursday Thoughts
(It's been a crazy few weeks and my work schedule has been temporarily flipped around, which means I'm working my normal ten hour shift on Wednesdays ... hence the lack of a mid-week post.)
I posted a few weeks ago about my recent short story publication, "For As Many Dawns," which was based on the fairytale / fable The Buried Moon. I adore fairytales, myths, fables and ballads, many of which share influences and borrow storylines. Often, the lines between these different types of tales blur, and classifying them is a matter of personal taste.
I grew up on D'aulaires' Book of Greek Myths and the varying Andrew Lang colored fairy books. One of my earliest attempts at a short story was a rewrite of the Pandora myth, where Barbie was Pandora. I've never grown out of the fascination. The title track of my CD, Rolling Of The Stone, is an Appalachian ballad which is a distortion of a Scottish ballad, The Twa Brothers. The original story is about two quarreling brothers, one of whom slays the other, and ends with the dead brother's beloved weeping over his grave. In Rolling Of The Stone, the focus is on the beloved, Annie, who uses her tabor to charm her lover out of the grave.
As a writer, I love using fairytales (myths, legends, etc) as the basis for a story. I think they appeal to readers, too, because the elements are deeply archetypal, often subconsciously absorbed. And because of that, there's an implicit understanding: you can take shortcuts or start in the middle, and (generally) readers will know exactly the landscape they've been dropped into.
I admit the lazy element, too: there's a built plot outline with using a fairytale. But then again ...
The fairytale is ripe for a plot twist, for subverting the expectations and taking an unexpected turn. How do you figure out where to turn? A great place to start is to take a good, hard look at fairytale logic, which is often poetic rather than rational. For instance, how in the world did Cinderella's prince find her by footwear alone? (I'm sure someone's written a story where the prince picks the wrong person because he happens to come across another girl with minuscule feet first ...)
Another fun way to play with fairytales is to transport them to an unexpected setting. I once partook in a writers' challenge on the premise to take a favorite fairytale and then set it in a speculative subgenre you weren't comfortable with. I rewrote "The Six Swans" as a cyberpunk tale, reworking the main character's prohibition against speech into being forbidden to plug into the network.
And the current short story I'm working on? It's based on The Flower Queen's Daughter (found in one of the Lang books, though I'm not sure which), and starts with the moment where the hero proposes to the princess he's rescued ... and she says no. The flashback explores a fairy's broken (or is it?) promise to him and the events that followed.
I posted a few weeks ago about my recent short story publication, "For As Many Dawns," which was based on the fairytale / fable The Buried Moon. I adore fairytales, myths, fables and ballads, many of which share influences and borrow storylines. Often, the lines between these different types of tales blur, and classifying them is a matter of personal taste.
I grew up on D'aulaires' Book of Greek Myths and the varying Andrew Lang colored fairy books. One of my earliest attempts at a short story was a rewrite of the Pandora myth, where Barbie was Pandora. I've never grown out of the fascination. The title track of my CD, Rolling Of The Stone, is an Appalachian ballad which is a distortion of a Scottish ballad, The Twa Brothers. The original story is about two quarreling brothers, one of whom slays the other, and ends with the dead brother's beloved weeping over his grave. In Rolling Of The Stone, the focus is on the beloved, Annie, who uses her tabor to charm her lover out of the grave.
As a writer, I love using fairytales (myths, legends, etc) as the basis for a story. I think they appeal to readers, too, because the elements are deeply archetypal, often subconsciously absorbed. And because of that, there's an implicit understanding: you can take shortcuts or start in the middle, and (generally) readers will know exactly the landscape they've been dropped into.
I admit the lazy element, too: there's a built plot outline with using a fairytale. But then again ...
The fairytale is ripe for a plot twist, for subverting the expectations and taking an unexpected turn. How do you figure out where to turn? A great place to start is to take a good, hard look at fairytale logic, which is often poetic rather than rational. For instance, how in the world did Cinderella's prince find her by footwear alone? (I'm sure someone's written a story where the prince picks the wrong person because he happens to come across another girl with minuscule feet first ...)
Another fun way to play with fairytales is to transport them to an unexpected setting. I once partook in a writers' challenge on the premise to take a favorite fairytale and then set it in a speculative subgenre you weren't comfortable with. I rewrote "The Six Swans" as a cyberpunk tale, reworking the main character's prohibition against speech into being forbidden to plug into the network.
And the current short story I'm working on? It's based on The Flower Queen's Daughter (found in one of the Lang books, though I'm not sure which), and starts with the moment where the hero proposes to the princess he's rescued ... and she says no. The flashback explores a fairy's broken (or is it?) promise to him and the events that followed.
Sunday, December 10, 2017
Song Styles
A few weeks ago, I asked about favorite Christmas carols, old and new. (And I would still love to hear the answers!) I just have to share one of mine, a song that makes me grin no matter how much of a Grinch or Scrooge I'm feeling, and one that stays in my annual music rotation:
Mrs. Fogarty's Christmas Cake
It is, of course, appropriately Celtic.
Mrs. Fogarty's Christmas Cake
It is, of course, appropriately Celtic.
Sunday, December 03, 2017
Song Styles
Surgeburnt is, in many ways, the protagonist against the world: she's up against larger problems to which there are no solutions (or at least, there seem to be none). But there are specific antagonists with which she clashes - and one particular character, Caprice, who holds a position of power and professes to be an ally ... but her background (and Maren's instincts) suggest that her offer of power comes with a price tag.
And now, in the current point of the narrative, Maren has had to take her up on that offer. What exactly will be the consequences? ... well, I know, but I ain't sharing.
In any case, Caprice is a gorgeous, glamorous schemer, and I couldn't quite resist using this for her themesong (language warning):
Wednesday, November 29, 2017
Anatomy Of An Idea: For As Many Dawns
We interrupt your (generally) regularly scheduled blog post to bring up a new publication of mine and talk a little bit about the inspiration. You can read it here:
For As Many Dawns
(I do recommend you read the story before this post, if you do intend to read both, as here be potential spoilers.)
The kernel of this story comes from an old fairy tale or fable known as "The Buried Moon." There's a bit of mythological this-is-why-it-is to "The Buried Moon:" it starts with the conceit that when the sky is dark (new moon), the moon has come down to wander the earth. In this particular fable, though, her progress through the dark forest is interrupted by all manner of evils, normally driven away by her light ... but when she trips over a tree root, the creatures swarm her and bury her in the swamp. The fable has a happy ending: eventually, a local village manages to free her. You can read a version here.
It was the idea of this anthropomorphized moon, and the power of her light, that carried into "For As Many Dawns." What happens to the moon's children after she leaves the heavens? I wanted that feel of old tales, of legends, to seep into the story. And how could a legendary problem have anything but a legendary solution?
For As Many Dawns
(I do recommend you read the story before this post, if you do intend to read both, as here be potential spoilers.)
The kernel of this story comes from an old fairy tale or fable known as "The Buried Moon." There's a bit of mythological this-is-why-it-is to "The Buried Moon:" it starts with the conceit that when the sky is dark (new moon), the moon has come down to wander the earth. In this particular fable, though, her progress through the dark forest is interrupted by all manner of evils, normally driven away by her light ... but when she trips over a tree root, the creatures swarm her and bury her in the swamp. The fable has a happy ending: eventually, a local village manages to free her. You can read a version here.
It was the idea of this anthropomorphized moon, and the power of her light, that carried into "For As Many Dawns." What happens to the moon's children after she leaves the heavens? I wanted that feel of old tales, of legends, to seep into the story. And how could a legendary problem have anything but a legendary solution?
Sunday, November 26, 2017
Song Styles
With the holiday season nearly upon us, already upon us, or in full swing (depending on who you ask), I'd like to pose the question to you: what are your favorite tunes? It doesn't have to be Christmas - I've learned the Hanukkah tune Sevivon - or even connected to a religious holiday - I adore Marshmallow World, popularized by Johnny Mathis (and mangled by a Target commercial last year, but never mind that).
So ... what special songs make you smile this time of year, no matter how often you hear them? Do they have special versions that are "right" to you, or can any artist sing / interpret them the way they choose?
What about ancient songs, passed down for centuries, sometimes fragmented and reworked? What about the most modern of new classics?
Tell me what music stirs your soul.
So ... what special songs make you smile this time of year, no matter how often you hear them? Do they have special versions that are "right" to you, or can any artist sing / interpret them the way they choose?
What about ancient songs, passed down for centuries, sometimes fragmented and reworked? What about the most modern of new classics?
Tell me what music stirs your soul.
Wednesday, November 15, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
When I first started writing, I thought of myself as solely a novelist. Writing short stories had no appeal - or so I thought. Even back then, I participated in fandom, and wrote short tales about my characters, though somehow - perhaps because this was for the love, never professional - I never really thought of that as "real" short story writing. Or maybe because rather than creating a story out of new elements, I was taking snippets from character backgrounds or transcribing / filling in scenes roleplayed with other fandom folks. I did short fiction for a fantasy e-zine I ran for a time, but they were all very much serials: (mostly) self-contained segments, part of a larger arc.
So I told myself I had no interest in being a short story writer, that I was going to write and sell novels, and I believed me. When I did start writing short fiction, it was with purely mercenary intent: at the time, novelists had more luck with short story sales to back them up. Then I found out - horror of horrors! - I really enjoyed it.
More than that: I've been working pretty steadily on my novel projects of later, but took a break to work on a so-called flash piece. (I say "so-called" because the first draft clocks in at 1,333 words.) The satisfaction of setting up the opening, keeping a tautly wound plot, and then - most of all - finishing the story was glorious. I've also been mulling on a couple poems - which, for me, entails looking at forms I want to play with - and brewing on a fairytale reworking.
I've come to the conclusion I need the break and the change in pace, taking a step aside from the marathon of a novel to write something more contained. ... relatively, because I am a big fan of the, "Yes, but ..." ending, where the current tale is wrapped up, but the story implies there's more to come.
Sunday, November 12, 2017
GoodReads Review: Blue Cats and Chartreuse Kittens: How Synesthetes Color Their Worlds - Patricia Lynne Duffy
(I don't usually post non-fiction or even non-fantasy books here, but this one so deeply involves the creative mind and perception that I had to share.)
Blue Cats and Chartreuse Kittens: How Synesthetes Color Their Worlds by Patricia Lynne DuffyMy rating: 5 of 5 stars
A fascinating exploration of the concept of synesthesia and the world of synesthetes, this book is both accessible and theoretical, personal and scientific. Duffy opens each chapter with a personal story that provides an introduction into the concept developed in the chapter, easing the reader from concrete illustration to the abstract of advanced topics. Synesthesia opens the door to contemplation of the source of creativity, the use of metaphor, and how the human brain regulates perception. A great, stimulating read.
View all my reviews
Wednesday, November 08, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
It's time to face facts and 'fess up: I'm not going to meet the goals I set back here. While disappointed, I don't feel I've let myself down or relaxed on my commitment to write. I've made some good progress, but life interfered in a lot of ways. The new job has been excellent, but very physically intense, and the commute is a bear. My older dog, Lexi, got very sick very suddenly. She's on the mend now and with a long-term plan, but it swallowed a lot of my emotional energy. My venerable Frankenlaptop decided to do a swan dive, which interfered with my writing because I'll to write in the evenings while chilling in front of the television.
Some of the delays have been directly writing related. I got my proof for Scylla and Charybdis (!), which took priority. I also decided to incorporate an element into the worldbuilding for my next project that requires some research, so now I'm down the blissful rabbit hole of learning new things. I'm also feeling like I need to stretch my flash and poetry muscles a little, so I may take a pacing break for that.
I've always been the kind of person for whom deadlines are liberating, but I'm also the kind of person who stresses over them and beats herself up for falling short ... so I know when I need to let go of the deadline and let things happen in their own time. I hope both novels (all three novels!) will be better for it.
It's time to face facts and 'fess up: I'm addicted to alliteration.
Some of the delays have been directly writing related. I got my proof for Scylla and Charybdis (!), which took priority. I also decided to incorporate an element into the worldbuilding for my next project that requires some research, so now I'm down the blissful rabbit hole of learning new things. I'm also feeling like I need to stretch my flash and poetry muscles a little, so I may take a pacing break for that.
I've always been the kind of person for whom deadlines are liberating, but I'm also the kind of person who stresses over them and beats herself up for falling short ... so I know when I need to let go of the deadline and let things happen in their own time. I hope both novels (all three novels!) will be better for it.
It's time to face facts and 'fess up: I'm addicted to alliteration.
Sunday, November 05, 2017
Song Styles
I've mentioned before that there are some thematic worldbuilding similarities between Scylla and Charybdis and Surgeburnt: both are settings that have "recovered" from the apocalypse; both address a backlash against current society's constant connectivity; and both put physical books in an isolated but hallowed niche, primarily because I am a book nerd and have an undying love for ink and paper. I even posited a theory that they could be the same setting, since the planetary denizens in SaC have long since lost contact with Earth, and I haven't ruled out space travel in Surgeburnt, at least not explicitly. But that's a bit of silly fluff and I don't think I'd formalize it; the two settings *feel* very different to me in other ways, and to me they don't belong in the same universe.
But there is one more thing that is similar between them. I recently discovered that they both have the same song on their general theme list:
Children Of The Revolution - Kirsty MacColl
(This is Kirsty at her best, by the way: it's such bright, cheerful instrumentation and the lyrics are biting, snarky and dark.)
The song applies to my projects in different ways, but it is definitely appropriate for both.
But there is one more thing that is similar between them. I recently discovered that they both have the same song on their general theme list:
Children Of The Revolution - Kirsty MacColl
(This is Kirsty at her best, by the way: it's such bright, cheerful instrumentation and the lyrics are biting, snarky and dark.)
The song applies to my projects in different ways, but it is definitely appropriate for both.
Wednesday, November 01, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
One of the best recommendations I can make for fellow writers is this: critique the stories of others.
We all take for granted the advantages of having someone else read our work, from big picture review to catching typos that our eyes just skip over, but even if you never submit a story to a workshop or post on a forum in turn, the process of critiquing can be immensely helpful to your own writing and editing.
First, it helps hone your critical eye. Picking out what elements you like or don't like in a story and - even better - trying to analyze why helps you be aware of flaws when you return to your own work. Read a tale that involves an act of deus ex machina, and it might bring your attention to a badly used coincidence in your novel. It's also a "safe" place to notice these things, when you don't have the personal attachment of it being your keyboard-borne baby.
Second, it helps you separate objective and subjective issues, especially if you read outside your preferred tastes. Is this battle scene and its gore over the top, or are you just not the intended audience? What about an unhappy ending - is this cheating a reader, or do you just hate them on principle? This kind of perspective is useful to have when, inevitably, an editor's rejection bounces back to you with comments, and you have to decide whether or not they have a point.
Third, the act of writing the critique improves a different set of writing muscles. An effective critique discusses the story subjectively and without directing its suggestions straight at the author - where comments can too easily be taken as attacks. Instead, a good critique focuses on how the reader reacted to the story, without much attention for the author. (Comments like, "English must be your second language," or even, "I assume you're a native, because your grasp of (X) culture is ..." are landmines.) This leads to using "I" language instead of "you" language, which puts people on the defensive in any context, much less one so artistically personal.
Of course, reading a set of critiques is a skill of its own ... but that's another topic.
We all take for granted the advantages of having someone else read our work, from big picture review to catching typos that our eyes just skip over, but even if you never submit a story to a workshop or post on a forum in turn, the process of critiquing can be immensely helpful to your own writing and editing.
First, it helps hone your critical eye. Picking out what elements you like or don't like in a story and - even better - trying to analyze why helps you be aware of flaws when you return to your own work. Read a tale that involves an act of deus ex machina, and it might bring your attention to a badly used coincidence in your novel. It's also a "safe" place to notice these things, when you don't have the personal attachment of it being your keyboard-borne baby.
Second, it helps you separate objective and subjective issues, especially if you read outside your preferred tastes. Is this battle scene and its gore over the top, or are you just not the intended audience? What about an unhappy ending - is this cheating a reader, or do you just hate them on principle? This kind of perspective is useful to have when, inevitably, an editor's rejection bounces back to you with comments, and you have to decide whether or not they have a point.
Third, the act of writing the critique improves a different set of writing muscles. An effective critique discusses the story subjectively and without directing its suggestions straight at the author - where comments can too easily be taken as attacks. Instead, a good critique focuses on how the reader reacted to the story, without much attention for the author. (Comments like, "English must be your second language," or even, "I assume you're a native, because your grasp of (X) culture is ..." are landmines.) This leads to using "I" language instead of "you" language, which puts people on the defensive in any context, much less one so artistically personal.
Of course, reading a set of critiques is a skill of its own ... but that's another topic.
Wednesday, October 25, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
It hurts my soul that for some reason, "unicorn" has become code for something chock-full of sparkles, glitter and rainbows, often topped off with pink. I don't know where this interpretation came from; My Little Pony or Disney, perhaps. Certainly, that's not the classical unicorn, which could be deadly if not lured in by a virgin, and according to some origin theories, was inspired by a distance view of a rhinoceros!
For as long as I can remember, I've loved unicorns and been fascinated by unicorn lore. The first plane trip I can recall, I stared out across the flat, mushroom dotted expanse of clouds and decided that it was the realm of unicorns, called Halunea. Maybe my unicorns were more sweet and fluffy than those classical stories, but they didn't sparkle. (There's a Twilight joke in there somewhere.)
I always hated, too, the old fable about the unicorns missing Noah's Ark because they were too busy playing games, and that song? Oh, it made me furious, with a dose of real childhood angst: I got genuinely unhappy every time I heard it. I ached a little. (I was a weird little kid. Move along.)
In any event, during my AOL days, I made contact with Richard and Miranda Gray, who created the Beasts of Albion divination cards. (I still use these for story generation. They're beautiful and inspiring.) The cards are divided into three kingdoms: Strength, Wisdom and Purity. The Spirit of the Purity kingdom, the "head" of that kingdom, is the Unicorn.
So we got to talking, and I brought up my dislike of the story. They agreed with me and wrote an alternate version, where the unicorns missed the ark because they were too busy helping other animals. I wish I still had a copy, but the memory stays with me.
Next stop, The Unicorn Of Kilimanjaro - photography. Check it out.
Oddly enough, I haven't written often about unicorns. A few of my short stories have featured them, but usually in an atypical fashion (in particular an urban fantasy story where they were shapeshifting psychic vampires). Part of it is probably because they are used to the point of cliche, and so I worry about overcoming an editor's reaction, but that's not the full reason by any means.
What is the real reason about unicorns? I have no idea. Maybe it's a silence of understanding; I know them so well, I don't feel the need to explore through writing. Maybe I'm just waiting for the right story, the perfect vehicle for my particular unicorns. I'll have to wait and see.
For as long as I can remember, I've loved unicorns and been fascinated by unicorn lore. The first plane trip I can recall, I stared out across the flat, mushroom dotted expanse of clouds and decided that it was the realm of unicorns, called Halunea. Maybe my unicorns were more sweet and fluffy than those classical stories, but they didn't sparkle. (There's a Twilight joke in there somewhere.)
I always hated, too, the old fable about the unicorns missing Noah's Ark because they were too busy playing games, and that song? Oh, it made me furious, with a dose of real childhood angst: I got genuinely unhappy every time I heard it. I ached a little. (I was a weird little kid. Move along.)
In any event, during my AOL days, I made contact with Richard and Miranda Gray, who created the Beasts of Albion divination cards. (I still use these for story generation. They're beautiful and inspiring.) The cards are divided into three kingdoms: Strength, Wisdom and Purity. The Spirit of the Purity kingdom, the "head" of that kingdom, is the Unicorn.
So we got to talking, and I brought up my dislike of the story. They agreed with me and wrote an alternate version, where the unicorns missed the ark because they were too busy helping other animals. I wish I still had a copy, but the memory stays with me.
Next stop, The Unicorn Of Kilimanjaro - photography. Check it out.
Oddly enough, I haven't written often about unicorns. A few of my short stories have featured them, but usually in an atypical fashion (in particular an urban fantasy story where they were shapeshifting psychic vampires). Part of it is probably because they are used to the point of cliche, and so I worry about overcoming an editor's reaction, but that's not the full reason by any means.
What is the real reason about unicorns? I have no idea. Maybe it's a silence of understanding; I know them so well, I don't feel the need to explore through writing. Maybe I'm just waiting for the right story, the perfect vehicle for my particular unicorns. I'll have to wait and see.
Sunday, October 22, 2017
Song Styles
I love this bizarre little song.
A quick summary of the storyline: the singer is addressing her ex-boyfriend, whose new girlfriend has schemed to get him to take her to Paris - the implication is that he'll propose in the city of love. And:
While she's in anxious anticipation,
I really hope you have a horrible vacation ...
Mon Amour
The combination of the quirky lyrics with the instrumentation just makes me grin every time.
A quick summary of the storyline: the singer is addressing her ex-boyfriend, whose new girlfriend has schemed to get him to take her to Paris - the implication is that he'll propose in the city of love. And:
While she's in anxious anticipation,
I really hope you have a horrible vacation ...
Mon Amour
The combination of the quirky lyrics with the instrumentation just makes me grin every time.
Wednesday, October 18, 2017
Wednesday Wanderings
Some of you who follow me on social media may be aware that Project Runway is one of my guilty pleasures. Those of you familiar with the show, particularly if you're caught up on the present season, may have some idea why I'm bringing this up. For those who don't know the show, it's a fashion design competition, which is an entirely different world, but still a glimpse into creative endeavors.
If you are following the current season but aren't current, you may want to stop reading.
In a recent episode, the designer Claire started to work on a shirt that was a near copy, form-wise, of the design that had won the previous episode. The creator of that design, Margarita, was distraught, couldn't stop focusing on it, even when Claire changed what she was doing. When it came out in the judges' panel, they pointed out that they borrowed from each other all the time. It's a natural process in fashion.
The grand wisdom of social media, of course, is never to read the comments ... and, also of course, I did. People came down hard on Margarita for whining, for being a diva, for not getting over herself. I think almost anyone with a creative passion would understand how she felt. Knowing on a logical level that an imitator hasn't done anything "wrong" doesn't help: it still hurts. And that line between inspiration and plagiarism? It's often mighty thin and almost always subjective, as is the line between when something is a fair-game trope versus a specific person's trademark.
There is nothing new under the sun, just different arrangements of the same pieces, yet writers bond fiercely with their designs. It's how we breathe life into them.
If you are following the current season but aren't current, you may want to stop reading.
In a recent episode, the designer Claire started to work on a shirt that was a near copy, form-wise, of the design that had won the previous episode. The creator of that design, Margarita, was distraught, couldn't stop focusing on it, even when Claire changed what she was doing. When it came out in the judges' panel, they pointed out that they borrowed from each other all the time. It's a natural process in fashion.
The grand wisdom of social media, of course, is never to read the comments ... and, also of course, I did. People came down hard on Margarita for whining, for being a diva, for not getting over herself. I think almost anyone with a creative passion would understand how she felt. Knowing on a logical level that an imitator hasn't done anything "wrong" doesn't help: it still hurts. And that line between inspiration and plagiarism? It's often mighty thin and almost always subjective, as is the line between when something is a fair-game trope versus a specific person's trademark.
There is nothing new under the sun, just different arrangements of the same pieces, yet writers bond fiercely with their designs. It's how we breathe life into them.
Thursday, October 12, 2017
Thursday Thoughts
A day late due to schedule juggling this week; I was working yesterday, and while it was an enjoyable day, it was a hectic one spent running interminably back and forth to the ovens (pies, cookies, cheesecake!).
Thought I would talk today about my ritual for starting stories and novels; not the choosing or conceptualizing, but the very first step in the writing, before those first words hit the screen like a bellyflopping diver.
(It occurs to me I do have to specify screen. I do all my writing on the computer, and am boggled by people who not only can, but prefer to write longhand. Admittedly that handwriting is both physically painful and awkward for me, quite apart from the whole left-handed, "Oh, hey, did I just smear everything I'm writing?" problem.)
So the first step is choosing a font. For me, stories have a particular feel to them; I might not be able to put words to what that feel is, but it's there. So do fonts. Here's an easy example: Comic Sans gets a lot of flack for being not particularly professional or serious, so it's a nice choice for a humorous story. Another criteria for fonts is that they need to be legible, but not too big or small, when Word is blown up to 150%. So I typically will write in 9 or 10 pt, but some fonts don't look good at that size.
Why do I blow up Word? ... let me rephrase that.
I've been increasing the zoom on Word since I got a larger monitor and 100% no longer filled the whole screen. It's one of those "feel" things: I hate a lot of white space around the text. It makes me feel detached from the story. It's also why I can't write in double spacing.
For shorts, I also like to futz around with picking a kooky, dramatic, whatever font for the title, though that doesn't have any serious bearing on anything.
Oh, the last, crucial thing: I need a title. Yes, for a writerly reason: I find that if I don't have a title before I start, it becomes exponentially harder to come up with one. Most of my post-writing retitles (I've had a few requests, once because the magazine had published a story by that same title in the previous issue), I've been pretty dissatisfied with.
Buuut ... also for a practical reason: file needs a title. Not that I haven't gotten around this: I have a worldbuilding file entitled ArbitraryWorldNameHere. And "She's Unable To Lunch Today" just has the filename of "Lunch." (As a culinary type, this confuses me sometimes. It may not have been the smartest choice.)
And then ... the opening line.
Thought I would talk today about my ritual for starting stories and novels; not the choosing or conceptualizing, but the very first step in the writing, before those first words hit the screen like a bellyflopping diver.
(It occurs to me I do have to specify screen. I do all my writing on the computer, and am boggled by people who not only can, but prefer to write longhand. Admittedly that handwriting is both physically painful and awkward for me, quite apart from the whole left-handed, "Oh, hey, did I just smear everything I'm writing?" problem.)
So the first step is choosing a font. For me, stories have a particular feel to them; I might not be able to put words to what that feel is, but it's there. So do fonts. Here's an easy example: Comic Sans gets a lot of flack for being not particularly professional or serious, so it's a nice choice for a humorous story. Another criteria for fonts is that they need to be legible, but not too big or small, when Word is blown up to 150%. So I typically will write in 9 or 10 pt, but some fonts don't look good at that size.
Why do I blow up Word? ... let me rephrase that.
I've been increasing the zoom on Word since I got a larger monitor and 100% no longer filled the whole screen. It's one of those "feel" things: I hate a lot of white space around the text. It makes me feel detached from the story. It's also why I can't write in double spacing.
For shorts, I also like to futz around with picking a kooky, dramatic, whatever font for the title, though that doesn't have any serious bearing on anything.
Oh, the last, crucial thing: I need a title. Yes, for a writerly reason: I find that if I don't have a title before I start, it becomes exponentially harder to come up with one. Most of my post-writing retitles (I've had a few requests, once because the magazine had published a story by that same title in the previous issue), I've been pretty dissatisfied with.
Buuut ... also for a practical reason: file needs a title. Not that I haven't gotten around this: I have a worldbuilding file entitled ArbitraryWorldNameHere. And "She's Unable To Lunch Today" just has the filename of "Lunch." (As a culinary type, this confuses me sometimes. It may not have been the smartest choice.)
And then ... the opening line.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)